Lifetime deal or subscription?
A lifetime deal is only a bargain if it pays for itself before you stop using the tool. Here is the maths for each tool we track: the lifetime tier, the plan with the same limits, how long until the deal pays back, and what you pay over three years.
- Lifetime pays off pays back within 24 months · 7
- Depends 24–36 months: only if you keep it 3+ years · 7
- The plan is cheaper over 36 months · 2
| Tool | Lifetime | Same limits on a plan | Pays back in | 3 years: lifetime vs plan | Our call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $71.10AppSumo Tier 1 | Sprout$99/yr | 9 months | $71.10 vs $297 | Lifetime pays offTier 1 has the same limits as Sprout.Deal and tiers → | |
| $799Agency Max lifetime | Agency Max$599/yr | 16 months | $799 vs $1,797 | Lifetime pays offDeal and tiers → | |
| $199Pro lifetime (10 sites) | Pro$129/yr | 19 months | $199 vs $387 | Lifetime pays offDeal and tiers → | |
| $1992-server lifetime | Pay as you go, 2 servers$10/mo | 20 months | $199 vs $360 | Lifetime pays offDeal and tiers → | |
| $240X (lifetime) | Pro$144/yr | 20 months | $240 vs $432 | Lifetime pays offX has about 900 cloud requests once, Pro about 2,300 a year: lifetime suits you only if you use your own API keys.Deal and tiers → | |
| $499Business lifetime (100 sites) | Business$299/yr | 20 months | $499 vs $897 | Lifetime pays offDeal and tiers → | |
| $279Team lifetime (5 sites) | Team$149/yr | 22 months | $279 vs $447 | Lifetime pays offDeal and tiers → | |
| $299Pro lifetime (10 sites) | Pro$149/yr | 2 years | $299 vs $447 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $99Blogger lifetime | Blogger$49/yr | 2 years | $99 vs $147 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $140Personal lifetime | Personal$69/yr | 2 years | $140 vs $207 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $419Pro Lifetime, 1 store | Pro$199/yr | 2.1 years | $419 vs $597 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $1741-domain lifetime | 1 domain$79/yr | 2.2 years | $174 vs $237 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $399Personal lifetime | Personal$149/yr | 2.7 years | $399 vs $447 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $299Pro lifetime | Pro$108/yr | 2.8 years | $299 vs $324 | DependsDeal and tiers → | |
| $2441-domain lifetime | 1 domain$79/yr | 3.1 years | $244 vs $237 | The plan is cheaperSee the plans on ToolsAir → | |
| $749Agency lifetime (20 sites) | Agency$219/yr | 3.4 years | $749 vs $657 | The plan is cheaperSee the plans on ToolsAir → |
Plan prices are regular yearly prices from each vendor's pricing page, not first-year sales. Lifetime prices are the current deal prices. Sources and dates are on each tool page.
Check your own numbers
Questions
When does a lifetime deal beat a subscription?
When it pays for itself well before you would stop using the tool. We call it a good deal if the lifetime price equals 24 months or less of the plan it replaces, and say “take the plan” past 36 months.
Which subscription price do you compare against?
The plan with the same limits as the lifetime tier, at its regular yearly price (the cheapest way to pay), not a first-year sale price. If a tool only bills monthly, we use the monthly price.
What about the risk that the company shuts down?
A lifetime deal only pays back if the product is still running. Cloud tools can disappear with your data; a WordPress plugin keeps working on your site even if the company stops updating it. That is why a 3-year payback is fine for a plugin and risky for a young SaaS.
Why does a lifetime deal sometimes cost more over time?
Lifetime tiers often have lower limits than the plan you would actually need, and new features can land only on subscription plans. Compare limits, not just price.
Do you earn from these links?
Some links are affiliate links. A “plan is cheaper” verdict sends you to the plans on ToolsAir, where the link may also be an affiliate link. It never changes the maths on this page.